Rahul’s ‘Belonging’ and the BJP’s Strategic Silence
- Shiv Mishra
In Indian politics, the role of the opposition leadership and the strategy of the ruling party have always been subjects of intense debate. In recent months, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi’s foreign visits, domestic protests, and remarks made during the launch of a recently published book have sparked a fresh debate in the country’s political arena. While Congress supporters view these moves as part of democratic dialogue and ideological struggle, a large section of political analysts and critics see them as an indirect political advantage for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).Foreign Visits and the ‘Star Campaigner’ Narrative
Rahul Gandhi periodically undertakes foreign trips that frequently make political headlines back home. Critics point out that these visits often coincide with significant political developments within the country or the Congress organization. Recently, his visits to Columbia and Chicago drew considerable attention. Addressing a small group of 15 to 20 students at Columbia University, he made sharp remarks regarding India’s economy and democratic framework—sentiments he largely echoed at the University of Chicago.These statements drew strong criticism in India, becoming a primary topic of debate across almost every television channel and digital platform. Consequently, the issues raised by Rahul Gandhi were discussed widely, from cities to villages. Political observers believe the credit for taking this debate nationwide goes to the BJP’s robust publicity machinery. Only time will tell what the long-term political implications of these remarks will be, but based on electoral trends so far, many analysts argue that such controversies directly benefit the BJP. This is precisely why, in political corridors, he is often sarcastically referred to as the BJP’s “star campaigner.”The Hyderabad ‘Bharat Summit’ and the Direction of Domestic Protests
Prior to his foreign trip, the Congress organized the ‘Bharat Summit 2026’ in Hyderabad on November 14, 2026, which saw the participation of several foreign politicians and thinkers. Among them, Italian leader Giacomo Filibeck questioned Indian democracy and the electoral process from the stage and raised slogans in Hindi: "Vote chor, gaddi chhod" (Vote thief, vacate the throne). The sight of Rahul Gandhi, other Congress leaders, and the Chief Minister of Telangana applauding this triggered a sharp backlash across the country. Even the Italian government distanced itself from the statement and criticized it. Critics believe that instead of benefiting the Congress, this incident also handed a political edge to the BJP—perhaps explaining why the BJP did not initiate any legal action in the matter.In domestic politics as well, the style of the Congress’s recent agitations has drawn scrutiny. Under Rahul Gandhi’s leadership, the party launched a nationwide movement against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in protest against the SIR. To escalate the matter, they planned to submit a memorandum to the Chief Justice of India; when the Chief Justice declined to meet politicians or accept the memorandum, they staged a demonstration up to the Supreme Court—the first of its kind in Indian political history.Earlier, against the backdrop of the purported ‘Gen-Z’ movement at Jantar Mantar, a sit-in was staged outside the Prime Minister’s residence over student issues. Following that, during a march against the Election Commission under the banner of the ‘INDI’ alliance, forcibly entering Akashvani Bhavan also generated negative headlines. Critics allege that these protests give prominence to leftist and radical elements who use undignified language against the Prime Minister, the BJP, and functionaries of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).The Andaman-Nicobar Project and Strategic Concerns
In the midst of campaigning for the recently concluded West Bengal Assembly elections, Rahul Gandhi visited Andaman and Nicobar, where he opposed India’s ambitious ‘Great Nicobar Island Project’, citing environmental and tribal protection. Many defense and economic experts believe that opposing this strategic project in the Indian Ocean region could serve China’s interests, as the project poses a formidable economic and strategic challenge to Beijing. Given that Sonia Gandhi herself also wrote a detailed article in a leading English daily opposing the project, it is clear that this stance has the full backing of the Congress’s top leadership.‘Belonging: A Journey of Love’ Rahul humiliated his mother
Sonia Gandhi’s recently published autobiography, ‘Belonging: A Journey of Love’, is also at the center of debate regarding its authenticity and factual aspects. One section of observers believes the book aims to gloss over the past mistakes of the Nehru-Gandhi family and bolster Rahul Gandhi’s political future.Rahul Gandhi’s speech at the book’s launch event drew particular attention. In front of numerous distinguished guests, he shared personal childhood anecdotes that visibly made Sonia Gandhi uncomfortable. He recounted that during his childhood, his mother would sit on his father Rajiv Gandhi’s lap during meals, and he would be surprised when he did not see the same at his friends’ homes. Viewed through the lens of a typical Indian family setting, this remark drew sharp reactions on social media and in public discourse. From the same platform, he also mentioned the ‘Varsity Restaurant’, where his parents first met—automatically reminding people of the 1965 chapter when Sonia Maino worked there as a part-time waitress.Pending Legal Cases and Questions Over the Government’s Silence
What strategy Rahul Gandhi adopts within his family and party is an internal matter. However, amid growing questions concerning constitutional institutions and national integrity, a section of the public is now also questioning the functioning of the BJP-led central government. People argue that if the government possesses concrete evidence in various cases involving the Gandhi-Nehru family, why has no decisive action been taken over the past 12 years?The Citizenship Controversy: On November 12, 2015, Dr. Subramanian Swamy wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi alleging that Rahul Gandhi had registered a company in the UK in 2003, declaring his nationality as British, and that the same status was maintained during its renewal in 2009. Despite several reminders, no concrete conclusion emerged at the governmental level. A private petition filed in this regard before the Allahabad High Court has since been withdrawn.
- The Young India–National Herald Case: This alleged corruption case involving the Gandhi-Nehru family has been pending in court for the past decade, with no final verdict delivered yet.
- The Income Tax Case: An appeal filed against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in an alleged tax evasion case of over ₹400 crore involving the Congress and the Nehru-Gandhi family has also been pending before the Supreme Court for years.
Strategic Silence or Political Risk?
The central government’s slow pace—or perceived silence—in all these matters is beyond the comprehension of the common citizen. Political analysts are continuously raising key questions:
- Is the government incapable of taking these legal cases to a decisive conclusion?
- Is the government under some form of external pressure?
- Or is this part of a calculated political strategy?
Whatever the reason, political history bears witness that uncertainty and strategic silence can often backfire. Even mythological tales carry the lesson that whoever nurtures a ‘Bhasmasura’ eventually faces the greatest threat from it. In a democracy, an accountable ruling party is just as essential as a strong opposition. The BJP must understand that beyond electoral gains and political strategy lies a constitutional responsibility of governance. The public wants concrete results, not just political speeches.In this context, the question becomes pertinent: in its strategy of treating Rahul Gandhi as its “star campaigner,” are the BJP and the Modi government overlooking a major long-term political risk?Rahul Gandhi’s politics has its own place, but one day, the public will certainly hold the BJP accountable for its strategic silence as well.— Shiv Mishra

